Conversation with Merlin [email protected] · Sat Dec 16 2023

Paraphrase, correct and shorten the following text so that it is connected and consistent: Transparency is a cornerstone in ethical data practices, especially in educational data analytics. This section explores the imperative for transparent data collection and usage, emphasizing the need for openness, accountability, and stakeholder trust. Transparent data practices instill confidence in stakeholder’s students, faculty, administrators, and parents that their data is handled responsibly. Trust is foundational for successful data-driven initiatives. Maintaining transparency enhances an institution's reputation, showcasing a commitment to ethical conduct and responsible data use. Transparency involves clearly articulating the purposes and objectives of data collection. Stakeholders should understand why their data is being collected and how it contributes to the improvement of educational processes. Clearly communicating data collection purposes helps prevent misunderstandings and misconceptions among stakeholders, ensuring they are informed participants in the process. Transparent data practices empower stakeholders to make informed decisions about their engagement with educational institutions. This includes choices related to data sharing, participation in analytics programs, and understanding the potential impacts of data use. Transparency aligns closely with informed consent, as both concepts underscore the importance of providing individuals with comprehensive information to make decisions about their data. Transparent data collection and usage help address privacy concerns by demystifying the process. When stakeholders understand how their privacy is safeguarded, they are more likely to be supportive of data-driven initiatives. Transparency serves as evidence of an institution's commitment to ethical conduct, mitigating concerns about the potential misuse or exploitation of sensitive information. Transparency creates a framework for institutional accountability. When data practices are open and accessible, institutions are more likely to be held accountable for their actions, fostering responsible behavior. Clearly communicating data governance practices, including who has access to data, how it is stored, and how long it is retained, contributes to an environment of accountability. Develop clear and accessible communication strategies for disseminating information about data practices. This may include written materials, online platforms, and workshops. Use user-friendly language that avoids jargon and technical terms, ensuring that information about data practices is accessible to a broad audience. Establish feedback mechanisms that allow stakeholders to express concerns, ask questions, and provide input on data practices. This reinforces a culture of openness and responsiveness. Acknowledge the challenge of balancing the need for transparency with the complexity of data analytics. Develop strategies to convey complex concepts in an understandable manner. Recognize that data practices may evolve. Implement mechanisms to keep stakeholders informed about changes in data collection and usage over time.

Transparency in data practices, especially in educational analytics, is crucial for maintaining ethical standards. It underpins stakeholder trust, including students, faculty, and parents, ensuring confidence that data is managed with integrity. When data practices are transparent, an institution's reputation for ethical and responsible data use is bolstered.

It's essential to explain clearly the reasons for data collection and its role in improving educational outcomes, preventing misunderstandings and ensuring everyone is an informed participant. Transparency also enables stakeholders to make knowledgeable decisions regarding their data interaction, aligning with the principles of informed consent.

Open dissemination of how privacy is protected increases support for data initiatives. It also provides proof of an institution's ethical commitment, alleviating worries about potential data misuse. Further, transparent operations enable accountability for an institution's actions, encouraging responsible conduct.

Accessible communication regarding data practices is vital, and using clear, non-technical language facilitates broader understanding. Establishing feedback channels is also key, promoting an environment of open dialogue. Despite the challenges in explaining complex data analytics, it's important to articulate these matters clearly and to keep the community updated as practices evolve.

ArticlePDF AvailableAbstractLearning analytics has the capacity to provide potential benefit to a wide range of stakeholders within a range of educational contexts. It can provide prompt support to students, facilitate effective teaching, highlight aspects of course content that might be adapted, and predict a range of possible outcomes, such as students registering for more appropriate courses, supporting students self-efficacy, or redesigning a courses pedagogical strategy. It will do all these things based on the assumptions and rules that learning analytics developers set out. As such, learning analytics can exacerbate existing inequalities such as unequal access to support or opportunities based on (any combination of) race, gender, culture, age, socioeconomic status, etc., or work to overcome the impact of such inequalities on realizing student potential. In this editorial, we introduce several selected articles that explore the principles of fairness, equity, and responsibility in the context of learning analytics. We discuss existing research and summarize the papers within this special section to outline what is known, and what remains to be explored. This editorial concludes by celebrating the breadth of work set out here, but also by suggesting that there are no simple answers to ensuring fairness, trust, transparency, equity, and responsibility in learning analytics. More needs to be done to ensure that our mutual understanding of responsible learning analytics continues to be embedded in the learning analytics research and design practice. Discover the world's research25+ million members160+ million publication pages2.3+ billion citationsJoin for freeAuthor contentAll content in this area was uploaded by Mohammad Khalil on Mar 12, 2023 Content may be subject to copyright. ISSN 1929-7750 (online). The Journal of Learning Analytics works under a Creative Commons License, Attribution - NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0) Volume 10(1), 17. https://doi.org/10.18608/jla.2023.7983 Fairness, Trust, Transparency, Equity, and Responsibility in Learning Analytics Mohammad Khalil1, Paul Prinsloo2, Sharon Slade3 Abstract Learning analytics has the capacity to provide potential benefit to a wide range of stakeholders within a range of educational contexts. It can provide prompt support to students, facilitate effective teaching, highlight aspects of course content that might be adapted, and predict a range of possible outcomes, such as students registering for more appropriate courses, supporting students self-efficacy, or redesigning a courses pedagogical strategy. It will do all these things based on the assumptions and rules that learning analytics developers set out. As such, learning analytics can exacerbate existing inequalities such as unequal access to support or opportunities based on (any combination of) race, gender, culture, age, socioeconomic status, etc., or work to overcome the impact of such inequalities on realizing student potential. In this editorial, we introduce several selected articles that explore the principles of fairness, equity, and responsibility in the context of learning analytics. We discuss existing research and summarize the papers within this special section to outline what is known, and what remains to be explored. This editorial concludes by celebrating the breadth of work set out here, but also by suggesting that there are no simple answers to ensuring fairness, trust, transparency, equity, and responsibility in learning analytics. More needs to be done to ensure that our mutual understanding of responsible learning analytics continues to be embedded in the learning analytics research and design practice. Notes for Practice This special section highlights trust, transparency, fairness, and responsibility as actionable ethics research areas in learning analytics. This special section features nine articles that offer critical perspectives on responsible learning analytics

researchgate.net

Read more about author Nahla Davies. Data Science and statistics both benefit from transparency, openness to alternative interpretations of data, and acknowledging uncertainty. The adoption of transparency is further supported byimportant ethical considerationslike communalism, universalism, disinterestedness, and organized skepticism. Promoting transparency is possible through seven statistical procedures: Data visualizationQuantifying inferential uncertaintyAssessment of data preprocessing choicesReporting multiple modelsInvolving multiple analystsInterpreting results modestlySharing code and data This article will discuss the benefits, limitations, and guidelines for adopting transparency in statistical practice. Well also look at some of the ways Data Science impacts business today. What Are Data Science and Statistics? Feel free to skip ahead if youre already familiar with Data Science and statistics. Otherwise, this section will serve as a quick primer.Cassie Kozyrkov, Head of Decision Intelligence at Google, calls Data Science the discipline of making data useful. Statistics itselfrefers to collecting, organizing, interpreting, and presenting data. Data Science is an interdisciplinary field that leverages fields like statistics, math, computer science, and information technology to make collected information useful. Today, Data Science is one of the leading industries because of the huge amount of data collected and leveraged by various corporations, governments, and people. According to Glassdoor, data scientist ranks number 3 among the50 best occupationsin the U.S. In fact, many of the top jobs combine information technology training and mathematics, just like Data Science does. The importance of being able to process data will be key to success in the information age. Next, lets look at ways to promote transparency in Data Science and how that can be applied in the workforce today. Visualizing Data Lets face it, an Excel spreadsheet of raw data is not the easiest thing to understand. This is why data scientists and analysts are so important. They help make sense of that data. One of thebest ways to present informationto demonstrate trends and outliers is by visualizing the data. Data visualization isnt just for interpreting data though. It can also help researchers explore data and build new theories and hypotheses. The key, however, is to leverage these visualizations for transparency. The power to show information can also be the power to mislead. For example, when comparing data sets through visualization, its important to use similar scales to prevent misleading data. Data visualization becomes even more powerful with active models and static models too. Today, data scientists with computer science experience can build sophisticated models that dynamically respond to user inputs or show how data changes over time. Quantifying Inferential Uncertainty A common misconception about statistics is that it can give us certainty. However, statistics only describe what is probable. Transparency can be best achieved by conveying the level of uncertainty. By quantifying research inferences about uncertainty, a greater degree of trust can be achieved. Some researchers have done studies of articles in physiology, the social sciences, and medicine. Their findings demonstrated that error bars, standard errors, and confidence intervals were not always presented in the research. In some cases, omitting these measures of uncertainty can have a dramatic impact on how the information is interpreted. Areas such as health care have stringentdatabase compliancerequirements to protect patient data. Patients could be further protected by including these measures, and researchers can convey their methodology and give readers insights into how to interpret their data. Assessing Data Preprocessing Choices Data scientists are often confronted with massive amounts of unorganized data. For example, data lakes are an increasingly common method

dataversity.net

Like many industries, higher education is experiencing aggressive digital transformation. Historically, outreach to previous, current and prospective students was conducted through in person or telephonic conversations. Today, communication from colleges and universities is mostly digital, through channels such as student online portals and social media. This is particularly important for prospective students, who demand online communication options. A 30+ year old strategic enrollment management (SEM) company is a leading provider of solutions and services for enrollment, student success and fundraising for higher education and nonprofit communities across the globe. They are one of many organizations in the industry who has spent years planning and executing a digital transformation to adapt to changing industry needs. They committed to deliver a new, robust and highly efficient online portal for their client base of more than 1200 higher education institutions, providing them a 360-degree view of student data at any point in the students journey. After 3+ years of development, the infrastructure that had been implemented was costly, inefficient and still not meeting the customers overall objective. Following a renewed directive by the CEO, they embarked on an operational data transformation initiative to update their antiquated and costly operational data processes critical to their business of servicing higher education. Their key objective was to effectively create a data marketplace for higher education institutions, enabling them to easily view student data and easily access analytic results through intuitive, interactive dashboards. Deliverables to further this objective included: Implementing internal and external data glossary standards to enforce a common understanding and quality of information for both internal organizational definitions and for the higher education industry as a whole. Consolidating multiple tools to reduce internal and external reporting costs Ensuring efficient end-to-end client file capture, data cleansing, transformation and data delivery (reporting) that enable: Improvement of current data processing performance Architecture support of ongoing data and advanced analytics growth Accurate and more meaningful higher education analytics and insights Read how this strategic enrollment management used higher education analytics and established an enterprise data governance program with a standardized, central business glossary and provided visibility into data asset location, usage and processes.

precisely.com

Paraphrase, correct and shorten the following text so that it is connected and consistent: Ethical data practices in educational settings require active participation and collaboration from various stakeholders. Students play a crucial role in advocating for informed consent. They should actively seek to understand how their data is used, ask questions about data practices, and exercise their right to provide or withhold consent. Fostering data literacy among students empowers them to engage meaningfully with data practices. Educating students on the implications of data collection and analytics enhances their ability to make informed decisions about their data. Educators have a responsibility to nurture data literacy among their students. This includes integrating discussions about data ethics into the curriculum and helping students critically evaluate the ethical implications of data use. Educators serve as role models for ethical behavior. By practicing transparency, seeking informed consent when applicable, and emphasizing the ethical use of data in their teaching, educators contribute to a culture of responsible data practices. Institutions must establish clear ethical frameworks that guide data practices. This involves defining principles for data collection, usage, and sharing, aligned with legal requirements and ethical standards. Institutions are responsible for implementing robust data governance structures. This includes appointing data protection officers, establishing data ethics committees, and ensuring compliance with privacy regulations and should involve stakeholders in decision-making processes related to data practices. This inclusivity ensures that diverse perspectives are considered, promoting fair and equitable policies. Establish mechanisms for ongoing feedback from students, educators, and other stakeholders. This collaborative approach allows for continuous improvement in data practices based on the evolving needs and concerns of the community. All stakeholders have a role in promoting clear communication about data practices. Institutions should communicate openly about their data policies, procedures, and the purposes of data collection. Establish feedback channels that enable students and educators to express concerns or seek clarification about data practices. Responsive communication fosters transparency and builds trust and should invest in continuous professional development for educators to enhance their understanding of data ethics. This training should cover topics such as informed consent, privacy considerations, and strategies for integrating ethical data practices into teaching. Similarly, institutions can organize workshops and training sessions for students to improve their awareness of data ethics, ensuring they are equipped to navigate and engage responsibly in data-driven educational environments. Stakeholders must navigate the delicate balance between achieving educational goals and maintaining ethical data practices. Institutions should ensure that the pursuit of data-driven insights aligns with the well-being and rights of students and educators. Acknowledge that fostering a culture of ethical data practices may require a cultural shift within institutions. Encouraging a collective commitment to ethical behavior ensures sustained adherence to ethical standards.

Ethical data management in educational environments demands the involvement and cooperation all participants.

Students should advocate for transparency by understanding and querying how their data is used, reinforcing their rights. Becoming data literate enables them to handle their data responsibly. Educators play a pivotal role by embedding data ethics into their teaching and setting an example of ethical practice, which helps in cultivating a responsible data culture.

Educational institutions need to define and adhere to data guidelines consistent with legal and ethical norms. This requires establishing solid data governance, involving data oversight roles, ethics committees, adherence to privacy laws, while also incorporating stakeholder feedback into policy-making, ensuring fairness and inclusion.

Open dialogue on data policies and objectives, alongside mechanisms, is essential for transparency and trust-building. Continuous professional development for educators in data ethics and consent, privacy considerations, and ethical teaching methods is crucial. Similarly, student workshops on data ethics are vital for fostering a conscientious data engage in the education ecosystem.

Institutions must balance educational ambitions with ethical data handling, prioritizing student and educator welfare and rights. Cultivating an ethical data culture might necessitate a shift within institutions, where a unified commitment to ethical is essential for sustained practice.

%PDF-1.4 % 6 0 obj << /Length 345 >> stream /CIDInit /ProcSet findresource begin 12 dict begin begincmap /CIDSystemInfo <> def /CMapName /Adobe-Identity-UCS def /CMapType 2 def 1 begincodespacerange <0000> endcodespacerange 1 beginbfrange <0000> <0000> endbfrange endcmap CMapName currentdict /CMap defineresource pop end end endstream endobj 8 0 obj << /Filter /FlateDecode /Length 195 >> stream x9 0 @E 76.RX$X(UtwCScIsMn>~dj endstream endobj 9 0 obj << /Ordering (UCS) /Registry (Adobe) /Supplement 0 >> endobj 11 0 obj << /Length1 11308 /Filter /FlateDecode /Length 6612 >> stream x: xoft5-[x Jr %h,-YR$9N r*)KJB m1M,nphHkf!)U{{4F;W:jB0!!Jo99it5:3,B<xx#`ha`1B(UBh>:auC-^aJ`}s* XknHe2,qaaH|R_ [x"!TGcbCGaWqbnCjS++sM:V i}_'8:RxE(]n9ib|xD=j@*e"hQ R@|%RRRwSI'uHB4peL; \QB!UKN=}X)::C?Qe4S /t?ABLP?;k{pzV]Sh'nE0F#h WA(6*|@7~h| 6Pe ZG!7u'qDWF}MA'?N9p5W^lm \P_7f\G*++f6dbkQ kaY NQBUE]vd;x +>vHd9\3Gv vIy=QlH,+$KR_&UnN=G*jwlV.R g%6Y*7cmWs)%?~+$;j(lP(2.!3fE",@DrHT+QnPyxkwQO?=j\r;@tJhfF;.fL&F(eXH6Gi.<6J^Pr/PRN%!reHVBKZY .(9 F'k7y-10"z p8d\. kAD/NwMk;nLpuI9v) $] ^NB']<\pHa#O< pr oK dJw#VytmDbAb+VnWw]8 )x&dU2[email protected] 00-$-ZvuX^0n3,t[eu]+,'o\dU'ROZ';d'u&Ia,X>9j0$./G*RAzT3[.)w:N. 5Zm94OJAC:KnHV1 Vme vCH [q02WWqd0T f5t`a!X>;)jLLn+KWW|N&AO_:6~(p+@PWT`'OK&Y{Xnwx86k)6e:}i/{oj\Bk,>iO%n^4j}+GYM6,r,^. =Bq'|E#TAoBK(eS8'_\C|Hz=(_5Hb~!h~(Ek R/I|b|`oL:pU',K%=H+M6 /:C-PnXi"I d)lE 1d 8!cr765'&WD'$/FHG.ft2_+ k N#<2dY O+f BJaxv)+.V5:DI&I>0=gS`T- Qj5j4f|e3|YzD-g6zWf5]s Pn-.//?S]|U5pnm-ufm MX3tI-J4:3H5/NbnbMgfnSow+!Xgjjru;Qgc14k&&{gV.uOPr3Y[iEC~-(/.`nn=Qw^W}j@K{}mccS271ox_/[,FJ4ZmyW(X ;3bVv|. jYhs^@u;u-97&TQ|NT%'>k&Dh efZ4Lsf;/8RQ5 prm V`Mm5LlmvXG)j{K=zz/:!tzWU "6*ZZh z 7dKrgHMuu{?|E5 /7J;v}+?"ezsyA%8=m6sV.JeH F=4kZIqOa_s'"z&nC}' k?pSjoj$-,sv45NbYWaS5cUf W9[#%TU9*?j(::GY=<\xAm+,a)hb_= ^f\V|HRV8mETI /0SVSz>y_| H'~WFM-DU{/,}6'7{|+/gz;psT^s!\OY'~RR`9ZO (\8bR}.I*(b85HM?.0(y|_g{pyA&T"E=k>]CiSCh@o~LNFi h3A~tmGnz(]??NN{gSD ;dFZTZegVz+/s5zPDnK;1^Jp-V%!z(ik7! AO&>x2 #7jHy<Mt(,{H %de pads;YNw|/ "2Mr9Mu yJ51/ux|s-\n WZ>7jU#yQ3>smJMP \GN=ZP*l|^Y:| Ox6[>A::?3_Q *ghjZ'\oW.TIWUJJR~<TVVF$ Z4 iyn3. :d6A iIU~FXkLZ]Q`=S+p|LmPjgGTc B_jO)0 L#BTS`( |kn|X2/(pU>yV&_U`*8ZaQlTW?g,eX ~a2,Ye?g,eX ~aBAs]P7 "P;@1%^8UDJag; $ pc> `a@CsdGH=|d_@+Md4p\,_j(kI"GUD91rag9'"JuArH QYO%w.\rT$3I*%_G'IMmr%-rgNg</'6L:pYKe? |**qGHW* kX#N B;6@{u5Umy;bxd GbHLH#jnQ( qncEu 1 9 a!p0B8nK}B(`xcOqb8!A@$P )scB 1\0%"U\H 1C-#Q1 DbX( E.2(o'`$ JUs} B8%-X6*,r .IDl88Ypn ~`(HdUO:K;liB}kX<;OS+E|PL1%b!!vGTt.\&`oBHpD0V{H$HPZl/2HlF V/1 'SYV0k+7mj!A NVkExE>yn$ xB~3 1N@rUs#aOep6'MDq*Bs|SN'^Ud]I ) Ca k nd8l>P"N<~q@-Y(9}\ _L7l7y(LLy0 ayV1{SQa<BVc?} i?&l:?ASc#[Qqw0Va0nd w@C0Q0#/6}9c?c~zI593uin} U~}n~vd 0F})^{HMYzlo6 5f<fqQg}llfNL JWdWVrT9T*j.WR>{oYlAihuFi?gJ4Zc-)1cFZJ2u6)koTkcURKsRJ1 I}c4\LkBLm}QgH~;fx 6o_)'SaheK%HU.oO]AAJg/_X%YV0b{gU[[gT9X?zh endstream endobj 10 0 obj << /StemV 87 /ItalicAngle -6 /Type /FontDescriptor /FontName /MPDFAA+Candara-Italic /Ascent 725 /Flags 68 /FontFile2 11 0 R /FontBBox [-402 -283 1071 928] /CapHeight 639 /Descent -275 /MissingWidth 455 >> endobj 7 0 obj << /CIDSystemInfo 9 0 R /CIDToGIDMap 8 0 R /Subtype /CIDFontType2 /Type /Font /W [13 13 217 32 [206 252 436 504 444 504 647 239 353 353 504 504] 44 46 252 47 [267 535 341 432 464 499 458 519 450 525 515 252 252] 60 62 504 63 [353 958 602 546 493 591 481 455 568 598 241 384 550 455 778 608 644 523 644 554 487 504 626 563 900 564 512 488 353 239 353 479 488 274 479 540 422 538 476 333 5

digilib.phil.muni.cz

2.1 Introduction and Scope2.1.1 ScopeThe goals on this chapter are to: discuss the fundamentals of educational data management, including issues related with data cleaning methods, metadata, data curation and storage for preserving educational data, and introduce the key Ethical Principles that govern the use of educational data, especially in terms of privacy, security of data and informed consent that should be addressed via transparent and well-defined ethical policies and codes of practices. 2.1.2 Chapter Learning Objectives Learning ObjectivesLearn2AnalyseEducational data literacyCompetence profileKnow and Understand the most common quality issues of raw educational data1.2Understand data cleaning methods for educational datasets2.1Understand the advantages of enhancing educational data through data description2.2Understand the need for data curation in educational data management2.3Be able to identify storage issues for preserving educational data2.4Understand the importance of informed consent as a key Ethical Principle of Educational Data6.1Understand the significance of educational data protection policies6.2 2.1.3 IntroductionThis chapter will introduce the second key competence of educational data literacy, namely, Educational Data Management.The first step in this imperative process is Data Cleaning. Since educational data comes from various sources, it could be really messy. It may come in diverse formats and it may contain various types of inaccuracies. Thus, it is essential to know the most common quality issues of raw educational data and understand the data cleaning methods for educational datasets.In order to add value to the datasets, educators need to understand the advantages of enhancing educational data through data description by using Metadata, usually defined as data about data.Data Curation is attributed with great importance in educational data management, in order to transform raw data into consistent data that can then be analysed.Moreover, to ensure continued and reliable long-term access there are many important aspects we need to consider and manage, when it comes to an effective digital preservation process for the educational data.Special focus should be given on key technical elements of digital preservation. The selected storage solution is of prime importance for digital preservation, since security and privacy issues are significant concerns.Along with the emerging opportunities offered, education data-driven practice and assessment raise challenges such as ethical issues and implications especially in terms of privacy, security of data and informed consent that should be addressed via transparent and well-defined ethical policies and codes of practices.Several frameworks, policies and guidelines have been developed to help institutions and educators to identify potential ethical issues and to apply clear ethical policies that govern the use of educational data.New regulations, like the GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation) have raised awareness of data ethics issues that can arise from data misuse.Informed consent is declared by most international guidelines as one of the pivotal principles in Data Ethics. The way individuals are informed is crucial for the informed consent process. Educators should ensure that individuals fully realize the expected consequences of granting or withholding consent.With regards to the collection of personal data about children, additional protection should be granted since children are less aware of the risks and consequences of sharing data and of their rights.As mentioned, in the light of rapid development of Educational Data Analytics on a global basis, new challenges to privacy and data protection have also emerged.Do educational data analytics challenge the principles of data protection? Is privacy a show-stopper? How privacy is guaranteed/secured, especially if minors and/or sensitive data is involved?Education professionals need to pay extra at

link.springer.com

%PDF-1.3 % 3 0 obj << /Filter /FlateDecode /Length 14844 >> stream x]+m+tus8@.\x3fCU RjKGUwz/|0Y?__t>7T`"zD g| 8)#~e/[9xr>M~_~ x^gC;Q<'|R4/T_m/b? -LGzU>FG<]Ns-t<h['.8c|}y9U'q*?Wn" t?z:uWB(zo8,`xh |X|v;p8Y;Ll^YQ^z}aL"wnyN%G?_*Rj=?A/8WxG5/V]Z%Tg;MlTY/0/# `|igA2yc{7b/-i208_c9b8ct,\YsY4o_>I@z8nw2P-,RNsR%Tvg~oORv9v?*r;\'.3G*7e$O%A B8j **.-Hy(LIKPzk"&J_[,,SOOm R~;\D#}~x8]ovFob?Wy9wWXInZzFM]SxW0]nkO~MJwv]H/& =~nrI?i2liIRtJ2]J2'}:/2}}KE\H OzR;w)sKj+]>!O.~{v !?E:kKt.Sa]`yoW'a$@_+m ,IFZ^x? Is7?~B%.c)zG|`_z '&; pKm7s,|6N"{m;,obp=vK&08#H>b,;Zf9.-~O|Nb? %t>]/cI ^;h+sOX-E"a\nxH33'}Y.y>2`:4i3hUl_Y\| -!L7`J0cRK7=i EBo0j1dtK?["#fyP `Pvm NlDqnq#3H 0Tlr`! 'w!6n<~!A g/ziA2~0A$}B%HM j_&a\8h'UG\BT )"/fD 8?2H2##Hpzh6Wj>H5~6lOMD&aNdi FB1*q6 ;I48IaQ3?Gf)G'EYqv$p[{S mk^;W@j5%D c5oF>K/mYk"&8*1TKnn7"c dsGQQR5S< H-58AH 6]C#,9qDnKC7 \I1'yce U,3^h`:]e[8YLWnpK( ?J:1?1d3g!W"XnC#&$%\0IYw@YBcIp(&)GayQNM Qa !P\Wfmh>K O6c5dHRV}Pr=-0, _t?I9=& ,yM+>&/zm)v\ N-k`/ NTM(l+v| =j/e,wH^]mO>K1( s39Dt-Bh")T% `P7 ~&%GF j1OnY UWu !a+ ";>867{*?[^t Ng%1Y nLuNIgY5t\0M@K2\#0eIZDsUbT~=Bf7_(;BucIXV`f rCM axrFTpsgQuZX`G h~ S+Z>N%n+ev&]\%i7$Co152fi ;:!l qQ)c4nE2LQg^]/ IF+OZ [wnJgr0$#~X\kIo\7KPpBcrH2Q'\3-OF\3 3^h \:3#Vo(>zzySSlv^Zc/ 5A{LVh%rF8J s$Js & jJ, }f~tFI ,2% %9;1A##q2k8++0e=]BN?SKy<FpV0peCrORFbLB?0f0^JPAabKT9`=sVpgU1h231 EDzm%E|pVT 5NI3kr1,O6ENISpo l+,O%#% TCyYCJ dFa4|l~ Q% JOL5UcFVFEJ+?ELB./`05R7EGy%|L>2u 2Sv2LW 'y0E/Bps3ZuJr"%2jG)* aG'J 3$2 E$,Z, I=Jd@hfRHr1/vC jR"QDcl"C<1I)`"(x$x<.D)%`1l(Uq@ubW_j<d zT(%)Hmkom8_L+Ns#265q&|:mOYh&Qc8hxc !6%b8mET"Im[n=w4o:3GO2h `4dsR(9 UC}h%iEE|[IzZ(~ MvRknMJhLO{0)+LFg UeR=ah:U4 ,!uEQ$FLTINQ2L0'>t1'k=<}K[Ee^x$CWml[2l}lGhQ:4T2B0 .9=kr43 @2ujhb"c@BJ $u<)O;m<~jtaltk/9@yhQXxp;U4cd2KDVC{Y]pWGKI#pKK Y<9{|( 3~82!&6r:K{~KfRAj[YFPsg%Y!Z !?06rO(YI#igCIM EK)` !=P*" 7pBe* m}&yR4I\|Bk4"PIYIwgc!V7!!3f!x!(.9}.%a|d!0L"41$;NPu%19Pg&A-b1-2Q]t"S4%s08L4LY/umC G/LNp"vd4!]NRBi~T!I&JR F2I^BI4p<"FoIZ>$Xy8O5Xtj 3*ZgX2}tQ-xYzxyq^S ;$}\ &Ev0elt.8X ry #hlE" +c7 2x852R:4E NqbbaBoC;zj2aiHuY8C>**1A#df[poOyUp&h -s#JbB_r.d=l0p |ZYM;Kt& ~ 4sfzf41I"?0 T.[Q9B358Qb0)t%z|~`Tc=4% 00[Yw(z-!/bR^Myy]<9+/D %gbF{`DLfkDfo7sc{O F`dXuBX# VC3'_'-hUdo3Sx$ ax>3O,d\]% ^Qm/( ~$qiE9Q |m437GaD*!n<<2[DubI Vb$Gsi|HW,ELN6HIVxYBWk^`T4`R_XI Z Yzd"&F8coRHM ,%'A'=(K #%(7l&4[hixEhQL8Nr6U~e:P(8L{9EX0U'@d%MaX<I}uh^Xp:A9u3nP->goi/E 0d|fru l:Za[|g#]g1.1Cm`8S^$~GrBZrS~f;maS+h'{kvBpG):QgMy4In6|^:>;zySq^fdrM0*iB5=piB4 R|JGv ]HTUW9;Jn~8h0>F/8{|<gV&R0[W{Q+EB-_$Y /F @k5aVSK?] p|hV h@ Nn1{sLcL#ic.lo]59J:z sU^Da 9WmlQhpj=EM~AhU*]S=z=@$nm)JU6n]5,;b "G}Lt rs_4riC-.+?z=mN :sXYJ[M[w:J$Po1)PqTr` Cv2~cX :s&ml'2p@3&5X?gWGomJk9;HXND#Bh'JI*j(mpt]K1 f3EY!~haNX{I<Ys#`4vfYQ`3p8!{o;?yun6IdkOC-x @ Y$4QvLdWT%B "u`@D}i0@ 'ty' d< 0!Yx|DIg~D!"Lr=I,%)2f8sS 3xH[x!CRH ] r8Fzp?Qw2}T(-40v[HIFl^w9PeYY0O?_0[7|jc_W g4yW#st_]$YYq6 . 9|5,nqI\oD3LF MgAL+\M{?ul#CS&jo5o1\FVeT;f6k"M>6+8^:'E,or- q\Cgf=]^7}j{V!smx|eM'v8+I 9f-X_iV%~~rl^Kz9~YN=}sg}}JT5O=.w1~+B9fHiO/c^=GEM &{ \z)8}gW'9"Od6;Z4iMUgP YOm<4d>gHw G93S'RfTR0r(LP(o)S2#ULju]$r.V0;w1&sv:K9g#eaQ~XYt#4 %\@)Q6rN+j/30B\q[H"d}KV]Ts`=7`xw>zJ/6o{<Ky6D\%zL%EIJZ7tjB`9lVyR*r/r yG7'SE^a_7';xnl^G}:[ hfN}Hiv:rZQ.t1* <:mmmtc%$ mP'k+5k*TZIM`hpvb*%ocZ_V9"][92ARg Mr\sB?5ZXjBs0[i,]KT*uAPhX`a]kb7JYIT\I#7MrW{.V0=6PlhD l{ulN@oZ [S3;xF__ia@7lx1GDL!!CFBHM

journals.sagepub.com