Conversation with Merlin [email protected] · Mon Nov 06 2023

Why the Myers-Briggs Personality Test is not Scientific

The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) is the most popular personality test on the Internet.:

  • It claims to tell you your personality type.
  • People tend to take the results of the MBTI test more seriously.

There are better ways to measure personality traits than 4-letter types:

  • Psychologists define personality as characteristic thoughts, emotions, and behaviors
  • Katherine Cook Briggs and Isabel Briggs Myers studied personality traits like extroversion and introversion

Myers and Briggs developed a test to apply Carl Jung's ideas and help people understand their personality types.:

  • They focused on four traits: trusting senses vs intuition, thinking vs feeling, judging vs perceiving.
  • They were inspired by Carl Jung but did not scientifically test their ideas.

Myers-Briggs tests are not scientific and their results are unreliable.:

  • The tests provide vague descriptions and career advice based on personality types.
  • Psychologists require measurements to be reliable and valid, which these tests are not.

The MBTI test is not especially reliable:

  • The test forces people into extreme categories of extrovert or introvert, which doesn't accurately represent most people
  • The MBTI test does not demonstrate strong internal consistency reliability or validity

Myers-Briggs has problems with internal consistency and validity.:

  • The MBTI treats thinking and feeling as opposites, but other tests show that people are often good at both.
  • Personality traits tend to change in different situations, making the traits studied by MBTI less reliable.

The Big Five is a reliable and valid personality test that predicts behavior.:

  • Many research teams have identified the same 5 personality traits, known as the Big Five.
  • Personality tests based on the Big Five have better reliability and validity than the MBTI.

Personality tests like MBTI don't say much about you:

  • Our brains are affected by various factors and new connections are always being discovered.
  • MBTI personality types are not a reliable indicator of who you are.