Conversation with Merlin [email protected] · Sat Dec 02 2023

Is marrying the daughter of my mother's brother okay?

Marrying the daughter of your mother's brother, who is your cousin, is subject to varying cultural, legal, and religious considerations depending on where you are in the world. From a biological standpoint, such a marriage is considered an avunculate marriage and, if the partners in the marriage are biologically related, they normally have about 25% shared genetic material, which is more than first cousins, who share about 12.5% of inherited genetic material.

Legally, avunculate marriages are judged differently across countries and regions. In some places, such marriages are legal and even common, with example countries including Norway, Chile, Argentina, Australia, Canada, Finland, Malaysia, The Netherlands, Germany, and Russia. In other countries, like New Zealand and the United Kingdom, these marriages are prohibited.

Historically, avunculate marriages have found favor in certain societies and time periods, such as ancient Egypt among ruling dynasties, among medieval and early-modern Christians with papal dispensation, and in certain Islamic traditions.

Specifically, with regard to Hindu societies in South India, marrying the daughter of a mother's brother is a culturally accepted practice, sometimes even preferred.

Ultimately, whether such a marriage is acceptable to you may depend on personal values, cultural norms, legal statutes, and religious teachings. It would be important to consult the laws and social norms of your area and potentially seek legal and/or religious counsel to ensure that such a union would be recognized and aligned with your personal beliefs and societal guidelines.

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia An avunculate marriage is a marriage with a parent's sibling or with one's sibling's childi.e., between an uncle or aunt and their niece or nephew. Such a marriage may occur between biological (consanguine) relatives or between persons related by marriage (affinity). In some countries, avunculate marriages are prohibited by law, while in others marriages between such biological relatives are both legal and common, though now far less common.[citation needed] If the partners in an avunculate marriage are biologically related, they normally have the same genetic relationship as half-siblings, or a grandparent and grandchildthat is they share approximately 25% of their genetic material. (They are therefore more closely related than partners in a marriage between first cousins, in which on average the members share 12.5% of inherited genetic material, but less than that of a marriage between, for instance, cousin-siblings, in which the partners share 37.5% of their inherited genetic material.) Avunculate marriage is permitted in Norway, Chile, Argentina, Australia,[1] Canada,[2] Finland,[3] Malaysia,[4] The Netherlands,[5] Germany and Russia.[6] In the United States it is permitted in some circumstances in two states. In New York a marriage between a woman and her mother's half-brother was upheld by the New York Court of Appeals.[7] In Rhode Island there is an exception to the general prohibition against "kindred marriages" for Jewish marriages allowed by that religion.[8] It is not permitted in New Zealand,[9] or the United Kingdom.[10] History[edit] Ancient world[edit] Avunculate marriage was a preferred type of union in some pre-modern societies. Marriages between such close relatives were frequent in Ancient Egypt, at least among members of ruling dynasties. Abrahamic faiths[edit] In societies adhering to Jewish or Christian faiths, such marriages were sometimes allowed. The Talmud and Maimonides encourage marriages between uncles and nieces, though some early Jewish religious communities, such as the Sadducees, believed that such unions were prohibited by the Torah.[11] Among medieval and especially early-modern Christians, a marriage between a woman and the sibling of a parent was not always interpreted as violating Leviticus 18; this was especially so among the royal houses of Europe, and in Catholic countries a papal dispensation could be obtained to allow such a marriage. Marrying own niece was also permissible in Islam. [12] According to Islam, Prophet Ibrahim's full-brother Nahor married his own niece Malika. [13] Medieval European royals[edit] Avunculate marriages were prominent in the House of Habsburg. For example, Charles II of Spain was the son of an uncle and niece, Philip IV and Mariana of Austria; in turn, both of Philip's parents (and therefore both of Mariana's maternal grandparents) were the children of uncle-niece marriages, one of which also produced Mariana's paternal grandfather. As a result, instead of Charles' parents, grandparents, great-grandparents, and great-great-grandparents adding up to 30 different individuals, they numbered only 23. South India's Hindus[edit] Avunculate marriage was common among South India's Hindus. Currently, it is mostly practiced in rural and small to medium cities. The most common form is where the elder daughter is married away to her youngest maternal uncle.[14] The wedding is usually called Maman Kalyanam (Thai Maman Kalyanam in Tamil Nadu). It was culturally preferred for at least one daughter to be married to an uncle. This is extensively featured as a plot device in many south Indian movies, such as Thaamirabharani (2007)[15] and Thai Maaman (1994).[16] List of historical avunculate marriages[edit] Perictione and her uncle, Pyrilampes Nahor, son of Terah and his niece, Milcah Jochebed and her nephew, Amram Ahmose I and his half-niece, Ahmose-Sitkamose Thutmose I and his half-aunt, Mutnofret Smenkhkare and his niece, Meritaten Pe

en.wikipedia.org

so, i found out that mothers brothers daughter (matrilateral cross cousin) marriage is, apparently, the most common form of cousin marriage globally. i looked at fathers brothers daughter marriage before, and noted one interesting feature in which egos paternal uncle (his fathers brother) got to pass his y-chromosome on to his daughters male children when she married her paternal cousin (because ego shares his paternal uncles y-chromosome). this is something a man wouldnt normally be able to do (since his daughters dont inherit his y-chromosome). so, fbd marriage is a really good deal for the paternal uncle. what happens in mothers brothers daughter (mbd) marriage? well, first of all, the y-chromosome doesnt really matter here because ego doesnt share a y-chromosome with any of his maternal relatives (unless everyones really inbred!). in the case of x-chromosomes, ego inherits just one x-chromosome from his mother an x that is a recombination of her two x-chromosomes. so, lets track her two x-chromosomes. in the case of egos moms maternal x-chromosome (i.e. the one she inherited from her mom), egos mothers brother shares an x-chromosome similar, but not identical, to the one that egos mom has. (each of them inherited a recombined x-chromosome from their mother.) he passes an (almost) intact copy on to his daughter (the mbd), while ego gets part of his moms maternal x-chromosome recombined. the result looks like this (click on images for LARGER versions): so theres a few bonuses for several individuals here: some of egos x-chromosomal dna passes on to egos son via egos wife (the mbd) normally a male doesnt pass any x-chromosomal dna onto his sons; egos daughters get an extra amount of his x-chromosomal dna via their mother another way of looking at it is that the mbd gets to pass on an extra amount of her x-chromosomal dna via ego; both egos mom and his maternal uncle get extra amounts of their x-chromosomal dna in their female grandchildren, and egos mom gets to pass some of her x-chromsomal dna on to her sons male children, something she normally wouldnt have been able to do. ok. so that was one of egos moms x-chromosomes. what about the other one? the other one she inherited from her father, so she doesnt share it with her brother. so it looks like this: not very exiciting. buuuuuut, what if egos dad had also married his mbd? thats how they do it, ya know. then it would look like this: as you can see, egos father would also get to contribute some of his x-chromosomal dna to his female grandchildrens genomes (via egos mother), something he wouldnt have done otherwise. so, thats a short summary of what happens with the x- and y-chromosomal dna in mothers brothers daughter marriage. let me know if you see anything else of interest or if you see an error in something i wrote here (i am experiencing a bit of a cupcake-induced brain fog after todays festivities (~_^) ). previously: fathers brothers daughter marriage and coefficients of relationship cousin marriage grandparents (note: comments do not require an email. or a family tree.)

hbdchick.wordpress.com

Tags Abusive Relationships and Domestic Violence Subjects Animals & Plants Arts & Entertainment Auto Beauty & Health Books and Literature Business Electronics Engineering & Technology Food & Drink History Hobbies Jobs & Education Law & Government Math People & Society Science Social Studies Sports Travel & Places 0Subjects>People & Society>Family & RelationshipsUpdated: 8/19/2023Wiki User 11y agoBest AnswerCopycan I marry my sisters daughterWiki User 10y agoThis answer is:More answersWiki User 11y agoCopyNo it will make the baby deformedThis answer is:Wiki User 11y agoCopythat's like marrying your cousin...This answer is:Add your answer:Earn +20 ptsQ: Can i marry my mother's mother's brother's daughter?Write your answer...SubmitStill have questions? Related questions Trending Questions How much does a divorce cost? How do you get the boy you like to slap your butt? Why is trust important in a family? When she says you need to slow it down but she calls you every day what is she really telling you? What is the spelling of the group who goes to a house of a newly wedded couple to play tricks etc - chiveree or chivery? When is boyfriend's day? Is it a good idea to have a relationship with someone who is separated? Does Ishaan has a girlfriend? Who is speaking in the unknown citizen? What is the first day by Edward Jones about? Do girls have spirm? Does Zak Bagans want kids? Ryan Buell is he married or dating? What do you do your ex-husband wants his new girlfriend to be part of his old in-laws lifes? Can your cousins son date your daughter? Where did the last name 'Huggins' originate? What if your BF promised to stop being friends outside of work with his girl co-worker and you know he is still talking with her just not telling you about it how do I approach him about this? What if your boyfriend lives far away and hes mad at you what should i do to make him happy with me again? What effects do genetically engineered crops have on young people? What does it mean when your boyfriend introduces you to his mom by your name and not say my girlfriend and what if he doesn't talk to his mom about you etc but takes you to see her often? Still have questions? Previously Viewed Can i marry my mother's mother's brother's daughter? Resources Leaderboard All Tags Unanswered Top Categories Algebra Chemistry Biology World History English Language Arts Psychology Computer Science Economics Product Community Guidelines Honor Code Flashcard Maker Study Guides Math Solver FAQ Company About Us Contact Us Terms of Use Privacy Policy Disclaimer Cookie Policy IP Issues Copyright 2023 Infospace Holdings LLC, A System1 Company. All Rights Reserved. The material on this site can not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with prior written permission of Answers.

answers.com

Tall me more

Avunculate marriages involve a union between a person and their parent's sibling or between a person and their sibling's child. Such arrangements were historically present in various cultures and are subject to a complex interplay of biological, legal, and cultural considerations.

From a genetic standpoint, partners in an avunculate marriage share approximately 25% of their genetic material if they are biologically related. This percentage is higher than what first cousins share (12.5%) but less than half-siblings or cousiniblings.

Legally, avunculate marriages are treated differently across jurisdictions. Certain countries like Norway, Chile, Argentina, Australia, Canada, Finland, Malaysia, The Netherlands, Germany, and Russia permit these marriages. In the United States, New York has upheld such marriages under specific circumstances, and Rhode Island makes an for Jewish religious marriages.

In contrast, countries like New Zealand and the United Kingdom do not permit avunculate marriage. Under the Hindu Marriage Act, for example, a marriage between a man and his mother's brother's daughter (considered to be a cousin) is not legally in many scenarios and contexts within Indian law, considering it to be within the prohibited degrees of relationship.

The historical context reveals that avunc marriages have been preferred or even encouraged in various societies, including ancient Egypt among ruling dynies, in Islamic tradition, and among certain Hindu communities in South India. In pre-modern Christian societies and among Jewish communities, these kinds of marriages were sometimes allowed with specific interpretations or dispensations.

In the medieval period, such marriages were common among European royals, notably within the House of Habsburg, to maintain alliances and consolidate power.

The acceptance of avunculate marriages in South India's Hindu society, particularly in rural areas and small to medium cities, is characterized by marriages commonly arranged between the elder daughter and youngest maternal uncle, known as "Maman KalyanamIt is important to note that despite historical instances and allowances in certain jurisdictions, the cultural views on avunculate marriage can vary significantly, and the legal status in modern times is subject to contemporary laws that may prohibit such unions. Thus, understanding the legal implications in the specific legal jurisdiction and cultural context is critical for individuals considering such a marriage. If you are considering an avunculate marriage, you should consult with a legal expert familiar with local laws and any religious or customary stipulations that may apply.

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia An avunculate marriage is a marriage with a parent's sibling or with one's sibling's childi.e., between an uncle or aunt and their niece or nephew. Such a marriage may occur between biological (consanguine) relatives or between persons related by marriage (affinity). In some countries, avunculate marriages are prohibited by law, while in others marriages between such biological relatives are both legal and common, though now far less common.[citation needed] If the partners in an avunculate marriage are biologically related, they normally have the same genetic relationship as half-siblings, or a grandparent and grandchildthat is they share approximately 25% of their genetic material. (They are therefore more closely related than partners in a marriage between first cousins, in which on average the members share 12.5% of inherited genetic material, but less than that of a marriage between, for instance, cousin-siblings, in which the partners share 37.5% of their inherited genetic material.) Avunculate marriage is permitted in Norway, Chile, Argentina, Australia,[1] Canada,[2] Finland,[3] Malaysia,[4] The Netherlands,[5] Germany and Russia.[6] In the United States it is permitted in some circumstances in two states. In New York a marriage between a woman and her mother's half-brother was upheld by the New York Court of Appeals.[7] In Rhode Island there is an exception to the general prohibition against "kindred marriages" for Jewish marriages allowed by that religion.[8] It is not permitted in New Zealand,[9] or the United Kingdom.[10] History[edit] Ancient world[edit] Avunculate marriage was a preferred type of union in some pre-modern societies. Marriages between such close relatives were frequent in Ancient Egypt, at least among members of ruling dynasties. Abrahamic faiths[edit] In societies adhering to Jewish or Christian faiths, such marriages were sometimes allowed. The Talmud and Maimonides encourage marriages between uncles and nieces, though some early Jewish religious communities, such as the Sadducees, believed that such unions were prohibited by the Torah.[11] Among medieval and especially early-modern Christians, a marriage between a woman and the sibling of a parent was not always interpreted as violating Leviticus 18; this was especially so among the royal houses of Europe, and in Catholic countries a papal dispensation could be obtained to allow such a marriage. Marrying own niece was also permissible in Islam. [12] According to Islam, Prophet Ibrahim's full-brother Nahor married his own niece Malika. [13] Medieval European royals[edit] Avunculate marriages were prominent in the House of Habsburg. For example, Charles II of Spain was the son of an uncle and niece, Philip IV and Mariana of Austria; in turn, both of Philip's parents (and therefore both of Mariana's maternal grandparents) were the children of uncle-niece marriages, one of which also produced Mariana's paternal grandfather. As a result, instead of Charles' parents, grandparents, great-grandparents, and great-great-grandparents adding up to 30 different individuals, they numbered only 23. South India's Hindus[edit] Avunculate marriage was common among South India's Hindus. Currently, it is mostly practiced in rural and small to medium cities. The most common form is where the elder daughter is married away to her youngest maternal uncle.[14] The wedding is usually called Maman Kalyanam (Thai Maman Kalyanam in Tamil Nadu). It was culturally preferred for at least one daughter to be married to an uncle. This is extensively featured as a plot device in many south Indian movies, such as Thaamirabharani (2007)[15] and Thai Maaman (1994).[16] List of historical avunculate marriages[edit] Perictione and her uncle, Pyrilampes Nahor, son of Terah and his niece, Milcah Jochebed and her nephew, Amram Ahmose I and his half-niece, Ahmose-Sitkamose Thutmose I and his half-aunt, Mutnofret Smenkhkare and his niece, Meritaten Pe

en.wikipedia.org

Home Family Legal Advice Is it legal to marry my mother's brother's daughter? 09-Mar-2017 (In Family Law) Can I mary to the my mother's brother's daughter(cousins) in which my mother and his brother has a blood relation? As per Hindu marriage act Answers (4) Answer #1 As per the Hindu Marriage Act, it is illegal to marry within certain degrees of prohibited relationships. The Hindu Marriage Act prohibits marriages between certain close relatives, including the relationship between a man and his mother's brother's daughter. Such a relationship is considered a prohibited degree of relationship within the meaning of Section 3(g)(iv), and marriages within such relationships are not recognized as valid under the Section 5 and 11 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. Therefore, it is not legal to marry your mother's brother's daughter under the Hindu Marriage Act. It is considered a void marriage, and any such marriage would not be recognized as valid under the law. It is advisable to consult with a legal expert to understand the legal implications of such marriages under other laws, customs, or personal laws applicable to the parties involved. Answer #2 If you are a Hindu, it is not legal to marry mother's brothers daughter I.e. Mama's daughter. Even socially and religiously it would be a stigma. Any marriage with a blood relative is prohibited. Morally also it is not correct. Answer #3 If your cast custom marriage (fui bhatriji, with uncle's daughter, [examples: Rajput, darbar, gadhavi] So you can marry. Provisions under special marriage act. Otherwise you can't marriage in Relation. Atul faldu, Advocate Answer #4 Dear Generally it is restricted to do marriage in the same sibling. In Gujarat many cast is having rituals to do marriage among the brothers - sisters of father's Sister - Daughter. Here you are not specify your cast and from where you reside. Thanks. Disclaimer: The above query and its response is NOT a legal opinion in any way whatsoever as this is based on the information shared by the person posting the query at lawrato.com and has been responded by one of the Divorce Lawyers at lawrato.com to address the specific facts and details. Report abuse? Comments by Users No Comments! Be the first one to comment. Recent Questions Guidance for compromise or patch up with mutual understanding Maintainance and DNA test for inheritance Received samajpatra from police Wife having affair and property related Adding name on share certificate "lawrato.com has handpicked some of the best Legal Experts in the country to help you get practical Legal Advice & help."

lawrato.com

(Querist) 08 October 2015 This query is : Resolved Can I marry my mother's brother's daughter's daughter Under HMA Act 1955?Will it be Valid?What will be the consequences? Guest (Expert) 08 October 2015 You are in the Status of the Concerned Girl's Father.Better to Avoid than Putting Every One Of your Family in embarrassment and trouble. niranjan (Expert) 08 October 2015 Yes, you can, Blood relation is much far and you are not in prohibited degree. malipeddi jaggarao (Expert) 09 October 2015 The relationship is not in prohibited degree. Hence legally the marriage is valid. But socially, You are equated with her father. Elders may not agree. SAINATH DEVALLA (Expert) 09 October 2015 Its sapinda relationship as per HMA,as the degree of relationship is Third generation from the mother's side.But in South India its being performed since many many generations.In South India U can marry maternal uncle's daughter,paternal aunt's daughter,and a girl can also marry her maternal uncle. Kumar Doab (Expert) 09 October 2015 The prohibited relations are explained in the Act itself that is cited by querist.The Act also cites customs. So if there is a prevailing and accepted custom that is to be looked into. Guest (Expert) 09 October 2015 A good, but senseless academic question.I wonder, if there is no more descendant of your mother's brother's daughter's daughter! SAINATH DEVALLA (Expert) 09 October 2015 Rightly concluded by the above expeerts. K.S.Srinivas (Expert) 12 October 2015 Keep aside, the law and customs, scientifically and medically, blood relationships are safe to avoid. SAINATH DEVALLA (Expert) 13 October 2015 Genetically marriage with blood relations and upto three generations of too close relatives is said to avoided.There has been many instances of abnormal children born to the above marriages.Even medical experts dissuade from such marriages.hence I presume the querist has got enough suggestions and the query can be put to an end.

lawyersclubindia.com